Random End-of-Year Thoughts

Chris · December 19, 2010

I hope everyone is enjoying the end of school and productivity for a month. I know I loved sleeping for 12 hours the last few days in a big, warm bed in complete silence. For those who were able to go, I hope you enjoyed Birdy the Mighty: Decode-if you have any thoughts on it, be sure to comment on Grant’s Birdy post.

There’s really no coherent topic to this post, other than that it’s all somehow connected to anime. Join me as I ramble about Bill 156, Mushishi (minor-ish spoilers), on anime recently passed, and anime in the near future.

Bill 156

For those who haven’t yet heard, Tokyo’s Bill 156 (which revises the Tokyo Metropolitan Ordinance Regarding the Healthy Development of Youths) passed just last week. Essentially, it does a couple of things, like add strict government/parental control on kids’ cell phone and internet usage (stuff that doesn’t really impact us here).

One part of the original ordinance addresses control over “ material that may be detrimental toward the healthy development of youth because of their capacity to be sexually stimulating, encourages cruelty, and/or may compel suicide or criminal behavior.” Basically, any overly violent or sexually explicit public content could get banned from general sales and labelled as R18+. The part of Bill 156 that connects it to anime, and is causing anime fans everywhere to herald the end of anime, is an expansion of this criteria:

  • “Any manga, animation, or pictures (but not including real life pictures or footage) that features either sexual or pseudo sexual acts that would be illegal in real life, or sexual or pseudo sexual acts between close relatives whose marriage would be illegal, where such depictions and / or presentations unjustifiably glorify or exaggerate the activity.”

Furthermore, we have this little gem here that revises legislation on child nudity (animated or real):

  • “Any sexually arousing posing on the behalf of children under the age of 13 wholly or partially naked, or wearing swimwear or only underwear, published in books or featured in film, must take into account of how the child’s mind and body may be harmed by becoming the object of sexual desire, and therefore parental guardians must exercise parental responsibilities to prevent and educate minors from becoming featured in such work or child pornography.”

What does this all mean? Basically, any anime or manga that the government deems harmful to minors (based on sexual or criminal content) gets labelled R18+. As you might guess, an awful lot of anime and manga fall into this category. If a show becomes R18+, it (legally) loses a significant chunk of its target demographic, which drastically decreases projected sales, discouraging companies from making anything that could be considered “adult” content.

http://minesblog.com/anime/files/2010/12/whywouldyoudothat_2-290x300.jpg

Some people see the bill as the end of anime and manga, but I’m not inclined to agree just yet. One might think that any criminal content at all would be tantamount to R18+ (like death on-screen), but notice that this kind of filtering was already present in Tokyo’s Youth Ordinance, prior to Bill 156. All Bill 156 adds is this “illegal sexual content” bit. Things like death, or smuggling, or non-sexual criminal content will still probably pass through within reason (if it’s passed in the last 10 years, it’ll probably still pass now). Mild fanservice, like occasional panty-shots, probably won’t condemn shows to the adult corner either.

However, note that a significant chunk of anime released in recent years does fall under Bill 156′s new jurisdiction. Shows like Yosuga no Sora or OreImo portray “sexual or pseudo-sexual” acts between siblings, Index probably falls under the “child pornography” rule (a lot of the female cast are 13-ish). As such, I’m a bit curious to see what Bil 156 does for the anime industry. I’ve never really been a fan of over-the-top fanservice-y shows like Yosuga no Sora (lol sorry Steve), and the new bill will force developers to look elsewhere. There’s a lot of potential for decline in the anime industry, of course, but who knows? Maybe it’ll be an…intellectual stimulus of sorts.

Then again, maybe anime and manga really is dead. SOUTH KOREA gogogogoggogoog

Review: Mushishi

http://minesblog.com/anime/files/2010/12/45603266_1246004317_mushishi_1-216x300.jpg
I just recently finished watching this show, and I feel compelled to say something about it. It’s a very interesting show, and probably one of the better shows I’ve seen in a while. While I might cover some things that could be considered spoiler-ish, there really isn’t anything that would ruin anyone’s enjoyment of the show. The plot is such that it’s not really spoilable anyways.

The premise is that there exist a unique, radically different type of lifeform called Mushi, which coexists with normal life on earth. Most people can’t see them, but anyone can be affected by them. There are a number of people who study Mushi to both understand them and protect people from them, and these people are called Mushishi. The main character of the show, Ginko (shown in the picture), is one such person. The show revolves around his travels and the people he meets along the way.

You may recall from my first post on this blog what I generally look for in anime. In order, they are: character, plot, visuals, and sound. More specifically, I enjoy shows with dynamic, developing characters in a coherent plot. I also like shows that have some second meaning, some kind of theme or message behind the anime. That said, Mushishi has virtually nothing I usually look for. The show is extremely episodic in nature, to the point I could have watched the show in reverse order and not have noticed anything different. The plot is not very original, and virtually every episode consists of some person contracting a strange illness, and Ginko somehow connecting it to Mushi. The only recurring character is Ginko, who is more of an observer in the world than an active participant. The other characters, most of whom are episode-specific, are decidedly average, and have very few defining traits, personality-wise or design-wise (if you lined them all up, there’d be no way I could distinguish between any of them). The animation and music, while done neatly, are not particularly outstanding. There is no overarching theme, no real philosophical message to take away. All in all, I probably shouldn’t have liked Mushishi.

And yet, here I am, toting it as one of the best things I’ve seen in recent memory. Maybe it was

http://minesblog.com/anime/files/2010/12/mushishi5-300x168.jpg
precisely because the characters weren’t vibrant, because the plot was episodic, because there was no connecting theme, that I liked it. Mushishi is closer to a life documentary than to an actual anime with plot. Despite its supernatural and fantastical premise, the show chooses to focus on the ordinary lives of ordinary humans, and their generally unfortunate encounters with Mushi. There are no real happy or sad endings. There is no real beginning or end (and indeed, the show may very well be achronological). There are no clearly defined protagonists or antagonists – while humans are usually victims of Mushi, the Mushi aren’t so much villains as they are competitors in an effort to survive. For once, humans take a backseat to the setting, and the show becomes just as much about what’s around us as it is about us. Mushishi is an example of what I really think “Slice of Life” should be.

The closest show I’ve seen to Mushishi is Kino’s Journey, as they share similarly detached protagonists. Kino’s Journey, however, focuses on humanity, while Mushishi focuses on life and nature as a whole. If you get a chance, I’d suggest watching at least an episode or two of it to get an idea of what’s it like.

Anime of 2010

I’ll admit, I’ve been rather lax in keeping up with the current scene in anime (I spent most of this year trying to catch up with good shows from previous years), and I’ve barely heard of half the stuff that came out in 2010. And maybe it’s because I didn’t see enough of it, but I feel 2010 was a somewhat slow year for anime in general. Plenty of lulz, but less srs bzns and deepfag stuff. In a nutshell:

Stuff I could recommend with a straight face

  • Angel Beats!
  • Baka to Test to Shokanjuu
  • The Tatami Galaxy
  • The Disappearance of Haruhi Suzumiya ( 1080p is out!)

Stuff I would recommend for the lulz

  • Highschool of the Dead
  • Koe de Oshigoto!
  • MM!
  • Ore no Imouto
  • Shinryaku! Ika Musume
  • Panty and Stocking with Garterbelt

Stuff that’s supposed to be good that I’ve been too lazy to watch

  • Shiki
  • Durarara!!
  • Amagami SS
  • Arakawa Under the Bridge

Feel free to roast me on my laziness/tastes in the comments!

Upcoming Anime – Winter 2011

Current Winter 2011 chart

http://minesblog.com/anime/files/2010/12/Zombiedesuka-150x150.jpg

DEEEEEEEEEEEEN!!!!!!!

I’m…really not sure what to say, other than…I spent the last year catching up on good shows from previous years, and I think I’ll keep doing the same next season. Everything I can say I’ll be watching is at the bottom of the page, in the OVA/OAD section (Angel Beats!, Kara no Kyoukai, Baka to Test).

If you heartily disagree, convince me that Winter 2011 will actually be the best season ever in the comments.

Index Ep. 11

  1. At first I was like ^_^
  2. Then I was like >_>
  3. Then I was like -_-
  4. Then I was like O_O
  5. Then I was like ._.
http://minesblog.com/anime/files/2010/12/omg-adorable-anime-girl-christmas-so-cute-300x240.jpg

Merry Christmas all!


Responses to Random End-of-Year Thoughts


Gene · December 19, 2010 at 2:00 pm

Aye, the law is being dubbed the “anti-moe” law on 2ch. But, let’s face it, this may bring an end to a lot of cancer that’s out there right now. Not to say Yosuga no Sora is cancer. Quite the opposite, actually. It should be noted that it aired probably the most risque episode the week the bill was passed, and that was some major brownie points in my book.

Everyone keeping up with the law should know that the reverb from this law is already being felt amongst publishers everywhere in Tokyo. One writer for BL comics already got turned down. Is this a good thing? Just the same conclusion Chris came to, WHO KNOWS?

Let history decide if this law is a good thing or not. In the short term, chances are a lot of anime producers may export their fanservice elsewhere. As Chris said, South Korea is already looking pretty good. A lot of crying is going on over this issue, but I recommend everyone take a goddamn chill-pill and we’ll just wait and see. For any of you wondering if this affects our anime club, it probably won’t. We always play awful crap and that’s not about to change. >_O

Winter 2011 is a jacknife in the balls. Not caring at all. I didn’t read your review of Mushi-shi yet because I am also in the middle of watching it (just started after finishing Tatami Galaxy). I’m also starting DRRR!! to see if its “best of 2010″ material or not. I hate 24-episode anime, and in between that and the new Company of Heroes retail beta, the beta already gains priority.

Tatami Galaxy was good, though. Definitely glad I watched it.

steve · December 19, 2010 at 3:01 pm

NO MOAR YOSUGA NO SORA-ESQUE SHOWS =(((((((((((((((((((((((

Actually, I doubt that. The eroge and hentai industry has been successful for how long now? It seems to me like this is an “oh no we ‘have to wait three more years’ (wink),” scenario. And even then it’s just loli, incest, and rape… oh wait, that’s all of it.

The winter season looks like it will be less than engaging (there’s a more up-to-date chart by the way). Bakuman is continuing through the winter. I really like the direction it’s going, so I’ll definitely be watching that. The only show that looks good in a serious way this winter is Gosick. Bones is the production studio for Gosick; Bones also produced Darker than Black and Fullmetal Alchemist, so if you liked those shows you might give Gosick a view. I’ll probably also watch Fractale, Infinite Stratos, and Kore wa Zombie desu ka? (ya, I know it’s deen. FU it has zombies.). Shaft has a maho shoujo coming out as well. I’ll probably stream the first few episodes of this to see if it’s supposed to be a “serious” maho shoujo or if it will be a shaft show. I’m hoping for the shaft option obviously. ‘Onii-chan no Koto nanka Zenzen Suki janain Dakara ne,’ or ‘I don’t like you at all, Big Brother,’ if you’re a weabo is another YnS, so ya, I’m watching it.

It’ll be a good season for ovas though. We get more Black Lagoon, KnK, MM, and Angel Beats. I’m thinking that winter break is going to be a good time for me to watch the 300+ GB of yet-to-be-watched anime on my hard drive, 14 of which are consumed by the Fate/Stay Night movie (hooray 1080 and FLAC audio) and another 21 of which are consumed by FMA:B.

Jack · December 19, 2010 at 3:20 pm

Your list has a conspicuous absence of Katanagatari. 12 episodes at 40 minutes each, that aired once a month for all of 2010. Characters are endearing, although the plot becomes a giant ass pull in the last two episodes, and the visual style is delightfully unique. Gene said he was trying to add them all to the drive when I asked him, but was complaining about how long the big files were taking to DL (they are around 800+ MB each, to be fair). Serious recommendation for everyone to give it a look.

I think I’m going to watch Disappearance again in glorious 1080p because not seeing Haruhi’s drool (which Gene promised would be on the Blu Ray) absolutely ruined the movie for me.

Winter 2011 is the season of OVA’s. A couple shows look interesting (Fractale, Infinite Harem Stratos, Todoke 2 because for some reason I liked the first and already turned in my Man Card for doing so), but I can’t wait for Tethe’alla 4 and Angel Beats Extra. Plus, Break Blade 3 and 4 in Jan and Feb. Whee.

Gene · December 19, 2010 at 4:33 pm

Oh yeah, Katanagatari was good. I liked the parts with all the words. WHICH WAS ALL OF THEM. I have all the eps on the drive now.

…and you best not be dissin’ my infinite harem stratos dawg. ONLY WOMEN CAN OPERATE THEM!!!

For reference, I found this chart to be the most complete and informational. There are a lot of them out there. This chart was easy to read and seems to cover all the important bits as well.

DON’T FORGET THE ONII-CHAN ANIME. OH WAIT I’M ADOPTED.

Chris · December 19, 2010 at 4:51 pm

Yeah, I knew the chart was a bit outdated, but I was too lazy to find the most up-to-date one. Thanks for the link, updated.

I’ve heard quite a bit about Katanagatari here and there, but never really got solid feedback as to its quality, so I didn’t mention it. I’ll probably watch it while hibernating through Winter 2011.

steve · December 19, 2010 at 5:18 pm

“OH WAIT I’M ADOPTED” = new standard setting for all incestuous vn, manga, and anime.

Oh wait… it’s like that now (less YnS lol).

OH GOD THE SKY IS FALLING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Gene · December 19, 2010 at 5:19 pm

Hahahaha +1 Steve

OH WAIT ALL THAT INCEST WASN’T REAL AT ALL!

Gene · December 19, 2010 at 5:19 pm

@steve

Hahahaha +1 Steve

OH WAIT ALL THAT INCEST WASN’T REAL AT ALL!

Chris · December 19, 2010 at 4:51 pm

@Gene

Yeah, I knew the chart was a bit outdated, but I was too lazy to find the most up-to-date one. Thanks for the link, updated.

I’ve heard quite a bit about Katanagatari here and there, but never really got solid feedback as to its quality, so I didn’t mention it. I’ll probably watch it while hibernating through Winter 2011.

steve · December 19, 2010 at 5:18 pm

@Gene

“OH WAIT I’M ADOPTED” = new standard setting for all incestuous vn, manga, and anime.

Oh wait… it’s like that now (less YnS lol).

OH GOD THE SKY IS FALLING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Gene · December 19, 2010 at 5:19 pm

Hahahaha +1 Steve

OH WAIT ALL THAT INCEST WASN’T REAL AT ALL!

Gene · December 19, 2010 at 5:19 pm

@steve

Hahahaha +1 Steve

OH WAIT ALL THAT INCEST WASN’T REAL AT ALL!

Gene · December 19, 2010 at 4:33 pm

@Jack

Oh yeah, Katanagatari was good. I liked the parts with all the words. WHICH WAS ALL OF THEM. I have all the eps on the drive now.

…and you best not be dissin’ my infinite harem stratos dawg. ONLY WOMEN CAN OPERATE THEM!!!

For reference, I found this chart to be the most complete and informational. There are a lot of them out there. This chart was easy to read and seems to cover all the important bits as well.

DON’T FORGET THE ONII-CHAN ANIME. OH WAIT I’M ADOPTED.

Chris · December 19, 2010 at 4:51 pm

Yeah, I knew the chart was a bit outdated, but I was too lazy to find the most up-to-date one. Thanks for the link, updated.

I’ve heard quite a bit about Katanagatari here and there, but never really got solid feedback as to its quality, so I didn’t mention it. I’ll probably watch it while hibernating through Winter 2011.

steve · December 19, 2010 at 5:18 pm

“OH WAIT I’M ADOPTED” = new standard setting for all incestuous vn, manga, and anime.

Oh wait… it’s like that now (less YnS lol).

OH GOD THE SKY IS FALLING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Gene · December 19, 2010 at 5:19 pm

Hahahaha +1 Steve

OH WAIT ALL THAT INCEST WASN’T REAL AT ALL!

Gene · December 19, 2010 at 5:19 pm

@steve

Hahahaha +1 Steve

OH WAIT ALL THAT INCEST WASN’T REAL AT ALL!

Chris · December 19, 2010 at 4:51 pm

@Gene

Yeah, I knew the chart was a bit outdated, but I was too lazy to find the most up-to-date one. Thanks for the link, updated.

I’ve heard quite a bit about Katanagatari here and there, but never really got solid feedback as to its quality, so I didn’t mention it. I’ll probably watch it while hibernating through Winter 2011.

steve · December 19, 2010 at 5:18 pm

@Gene

“OH WAIT I’M ADOPTED” = new standard setting for all incestuous vn, manga, and anime.

Oh wait… it’s like that now (less YnS lol).

OH GOD THE SKY IS FALLING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Gene · December 19, 2010 at 5:19 pm

Hahahaha +1 Steve

OH WAIT ALL THAT INCEST WASN’T REAL AT ALL!

Gene · December 19, 2010 at 5:19 pm

@steve

Hahahaha +1 Steve

OH WAIT ALL THAT INCEST WASN’T REAL AT ALL!

Manga Therapy · January 5, 2011 at 2:11 pm

The bill is just another case of mishandling the issue of responsibility. I didn’t know that Japan can’t trust parents, just like everyone else.

I posted some thoughts on what the law says about people in general. You can read it at: http://www.mangatherapy.com/post/2609971604/youth-ordinance-bill

With the manga publishers fighting this law like crazy, we might experience a huge shift in how Japan progresses in the future.

Gene · January 5, 2011 at 7:23 pm

They’re fighting it like crazy, are they? I have yet to see any of them actually fighting it. I hear they’re bending over and taking it though.

Gene · January 5, 2011 at 7:23 pm

@Manga Therapy
They’re fighting it like crazy, are they? I have yet to see any of them actually fighting it. I hear they’re bending over and taking it though.